NEW DVD PLAYER vs. OLD CD PLAYER

[Kobus]

I curently use a "top end" Pioneer 868 dvd player for my 2 channel listening as well. I have in storage a +-15 year old yamaha CD player (CDX 530) (not used much - ie. in perfect condition).

I was just wondering if the technology that yamaha used back then in a dedicated cd player can stand up against a current "top end" dvd player for 2 channel audio.

I know I can test this and will, or will I be wasting my time ?. In other words is there a chance of the yamaha souding better.

Kobus

[aud19]

I don't know about that Yamaha model in particular but a lot of older CD players used some pretty good quality parts. I'd say it's at least worth a listen to compare

[Shane Martin]

I wouldn't be surprised if you felt the older cd player to be better. DVD players are a compromise for redbook listening. There is a good reason why folks end up modifying them to improve 2 channel performance

In all respects I wouldn't consider the Pioneer to be "top end dvd" either. Top end dvd screams to me Classe, McIntosh, Denon 5910 etc.

[Kobus]

Thank you

I wouldn't consider the Pioneer to be "top end dvd"

I meant "top end" pioneer, like in best they have to offer.


Kobus

[Martyn]

I replaced my c. 1985 Marantz CD player with a Denon 3300 about 3 years ago. The Marantz was terrific in its day, but the Denon was noticeably better. I would expect your Pioneer to be better again.

Martyn

[bleeding ears]

I have found my Onkyo dvd player to be better in some ways compared to my older Rotel 965bx cd player, in 2 channel.

The onkyo has more detail and clarity and tighter bass.

The Rotel is a tad smoother at very loud volumes but does seem to be just a tad duller or veiled particularly at low volumes.

It is not a huge difference, and probably depends on what components are being used, cables ,room etc and what your hearing is like. LOL

Have a good long listen and use the same cables (preferably analogue) on both players to make it a fair comparison.

Only you can say what sounds better to you.

Let us know your findings.

[comeup]

My Denon 3910 dvd player sounds better than anything in my house and that includes a 199$ HK, 300$ Sony and a 699$ Rotel cd player. Some guys on another thread are talking about a Cambridge Audio cd player for 599$ I will be checking that one out for my self. The top of the line Pioneer AI 59 dvd player has a better sound than my Denon, I owned it shortly, but returned it for an video issue, but the sound on it was awesome.