Rotel vs NAD / Denon Combo

[Viperv10]

I am looking for opinions on two different packages:

Seperates:
Processor: RSP-1068
AMP: RMB-1075
DVD: RDV-1050

OR

Processor: NAD T163
AMP: NAD C272 x 3 ( 2 x 150watt)
DVD: Denon 2910

-----------------
A/V Recievers:

NAD T763

OR

ROTEL RSX-1056

------------------

Speakers for both:
Front: Paradigm Monitor 7
Centre: CC-370
Rear: Mini Monitor
Sub: PS-1200 or PW-2200

---------------

System will mainly be used for Home Theater.

thanks.

[aud19]

I vote 1068/1075 with the 2910 just to be difficult

[DelRay]

I'll also have to say the 1068/1075. Don't know which dvd player would be best. If the Denon has sacd/dvd-a capabilities, I would lean towards it. As far as subs go, I love my PW2200's. It's a kicking sub.

[Charl]

Ok, I'll be the odd one out. :twisted:


Firstly, if you have the choice, go for seperates rather than a receiver. This way you can keep your amp/s and only need to upgrade the pre/pro when the need arises or when they release 'newer' processing or decoding technology. Seperates are also said to deliver superior performance compared with an 'all-in-one' receiver such as the T763 or RSX-1056.

I have owned both the C272 and RMB-1075, and used both with the NAD T163 pre/pro. My personal choice would be the C272's for sure.

NAD is famous for its warm, musical sound, while the Rotel has a more clinical / neutral sound with crisper highs.
Of course, much depends on your sound preference and also your listening room. I have a fairly 'bright' room, so I found the Rotel to be a little harsh for my taste.

To use 3 x C272's :E would be enough to drive any speakers loud and clear, with that sweet NAD midrange and overall musicality.

I have not tried the RSP-1068, but of course both these Rotel products are well-reviewed and generally very well received.
Have you compared specs and features for the NAD and Rotel pre/pro's?

For the DVD my choice would be Denon, as it is newer (won't be outdated / replaced soon), has superior video processing (also DVI & HDMI), and also plays SACD as well as DVD-Audio. Doesn't look as cool as the RDV-1050 though!


In the end I can safely say that you can't go wrong with any of the products you are considering - they all offer fantastic value for money! But, as always, it would be best to do a demo before making your final decision.

My 2 cents...

Cheers,
Charl